Tuesday, July 16, 2013

History and its Biases

It has been a well known, but unspoken, fact that social studies text books focus on the wonderment of how our nation was created and all of the "good" that the white men of history have done to bring our nation to the forefront of development and progress.  Is this truly educating students on the real history of our nation? Why do text books gloss over topics such as the Trail of Tears or Slavery?  Is it because they are topics that make white text book publishers uncomfortable?  Well, it should; these are uncomfortable topics that show a different side of the creation of our nation but topics that are very a much an integral part of why our nation is the way it is today.  
Would we have had a civil rights movement without slavery?  I am inclined to say "No" we would not have. Would we continue to experience racial tensions in our country had slavery not existed?  Many diverse backgrounds immigrated to this country and helped create the rich blend of a variety of heritages.  Do these groups feel the same racial tensions?  If not is it because they were allowed to choose to come to this country freely?
These are the kinds of critical questions students should be allowed to discuss within a social studies class.  If students aren't given the opportunity to wrestle through these difficult questions how then can our country truly move forward to blending the lines of racial and cultural diversity?  We can no longer afford to shelter our students from learning about how other government powers are run or how different cultures view woman and children.  Students need to be able to engage in comparing and contrasting different view points, increase their radius of understanding and pose challenging questions about fairness and change.  If we don't inform and allow exploration and discussion of hard topics within our classroom we will be doing a disservice to our country's future by creating a group of citizens who only see things from one point of view ( the text books) and with things being either right or wrong.
When doing my history assessment I wasn't complete surprised that neither of the boys I worked with could name a famous woman from history.  I wasn't shocked because I have seen how little focus is placed on woman who have helped shape our nation.  How can we expect the females in our class to connect with what they can do to be a voice in our future?  How can they see themselves as change makers if we don't show and model what that looks like for them?  

For students with learning disabilities I think creating an engaging curriculum that allows for a wide variety of ways for students to interact with the concept is key.  Simply reading from a text book does not engage the majority of students; especially those who have been diagnosed with a learning disability.  By providing learning experiences that have the students utilizing technology or role-playing or creating a hands on display / model will engage a wide variety of learners and allow the teacher to highlight the strengths of each student.  

For students who are English language learners there are many historically significant occurrences where these students could share their understanding from the view point of "the other side".  These students may be able to provide a perspective that can not be done simply through critical thinking questions.  Curriculum wise, teachers need to provide as much visual material and repetition of key pieces of information as possible in order to help this group of students make connections and develop deeper understanding.  Being exposed to the English language is the best way for these students to grow stronger in their understanding so I definitely feel it is important for these students to be in the classroom as much as possible with a resource teacher pushing in to provide necessary academic assistance.  Since the traditional social studies curriculum has focused on reading and writing skills I think the same strategies that are used for students who have a diagnosed learning disability can also provide a deeper connection to the curriculum.  By providing a variety of learning experiences that incorporate technology, creating or role-playing students will be able to display their strengths rather than struggling through their weaknesses.    

1 comment:

  1. Thoughtful post with good ideas for how to help students engage in critical conversations safely in your classroom.

    ReplyDelete